It started innocently enough. Sales were slow in March, so she ran a 15% off promotion to “get things moving.” Orders poured in, online shoppers were happy, and she hit her monthly target with two weeks to spare.

By July, she was running 25% off sales twice a month because anything less felt pointless. E-commerce customers had learned to ignore her regular emails and wait for the discount code. Her margins were getting squeezed, and she realized with horror that she had no idea who would buy from her at full price anymore.

The trap had closed so gradually she didn’t see it happening. Each month she needed bigger promotions to move the same amount of product.

That’s the quiet cost of leading with price. What feels like a quick win today becomes the cage you live in tomorrow.

Why a Discounting Strategy Sometimes Feels Like the Only Option

When you’re staring at a slow month or watching competitors slash prices, discounting feels like the most obvious lever to pull. It’s immediate, it’s measurable, and it works. Put up a 20% off banner and watch the orders roll in within hours.

The psychology makes complete sense. Online shoppers get that dopamine hit from “saving money,” you get the cash flow boost you need, and everyone walks away feeling good about the transaction. It’s the marketing equivalent of eating cookies for breakfast. Delicious in the moment, but you’ll pay for it later.

The real issue runs deeper than whether discounting works at the moment. Most e-commerce brands reach for price cuts when they’re actually dealing with a clarity problem. When customers need a discount to feel confident about buying, that usually means your value proposition isn’t coming through clearly enough to justify your regular prices.

Maybe your positioning is too vague and people can’t tell how you’re different from three other options in their browser tabs. Maybe your product pages don’t address the specific hesitations online shoppers have, so they’re price shopping by default. Maybe your reviews and social proof aren’t strong enough to justify premium pricing, or your checkout flow feels sketchy enough that a discount becomes the trust signal that pushes them over the edge. When your website reflects good service, customers feel confident buying at full price.

These are all fixable problems that don’t require training your customers to expect 25% off every few weeks. But fixing positioning and proof takes more thought than copying a discount template from your last campaign, which is why so many e-commerce brands end up in the discount trap without realizing how they got there.

When discounting becomes your primary growth engine, you’re essentially building a business model around attracting the most price-sensitive customers in your market. These are the people who will leave the moment someone offers a better deal and who expect every interaction to come with some kind of financial incentive.

How Discounting Impacts Profit Margins and Brand Positioning

Here’s what my friend discovered nine months into her discount spiral: she wasn’t only losing margin on each sale, she was rewiring her entire customer base to devalue her work.

Her email open rates stayed decent, but click-through rates plummeted unless there was a promise of savings. Shoppers would add items to their cart and then abandon them, clearly waiting for the next promotion.

The worst part was watching her brand perception shift in real time. What started as a premium product with a loyal following slowly became just another option in the “deals” category. Her customers stopped talking about quality or results in reviews and started focusing on whether they got a good price. She’d accidentally taught them that her regular prices weren’t worth paying.

This is what pricing power erosion looks like in practice. Every discount chips away at the perceived value of your full-price offering. When customers consistently see your product marked down 20-30%, that sale price starts feeling like the “real” price, and your regular pricing starts feeling inflated. (Have you ever bought something full price at Kohl’s? Me neither.)

You also start attracting a fundamentally different customer. The people who buy because of deep discounts aren’t usually the same people who become brand evangelists, leave detailed positive reviews, or refer their friends. They’re transaction-focused, not relationship-focused, which means your customer lifetime value drops even beyond the margin compression from discounting.

The math gets ugly fast. If you’re regularly discounting 25%, you need to sell 33% more units just to generate the same revenue. Factor in increased return rates and the opportunity cost of not building real brand equity, and you’re working significantly harder for worse business outcomes.

Most e-commerce founders don’t realize how far they’ve fallen into this trap until they try to sell at full price again and discover their customers have been thoroughly trained to wait them out.

How to Build Pricing Power Instead

You don’t need complicated tactics to escape discount dependency, just more strategic thinking than copying someone else’s 30% off template.

Real pricing power comes from customers understanding exactly why your product is worth the investment and feeling confident that you’ll deliver on that promise. This means getting specific about your value proposition, proving it consistently, and making the buying experience smooth enough that price becomes a secondary consideration.

Get specific about your positioning instead of using the same vague language as everyone else – Instead of being “high-quality” or “premium” like everyone else claims to be, get specific about who you serve and what problem you solve better than anyone else. One client revised their product descriptions to include more specific technical specs and use cases, and saw an uptick in traffic referred from ChatGPT because the clearer positioning helped AI to understand and recommend their products.

Build proof that people can verify – Customer reviews, case studies, and user-generated content become your pricing justification. When someone can read detailed reviews from people like them explaining exactly how your product solved their specific problem, they’re much less likely to comparison shop on price alone. Reviews that mention specific results work much better than generic “great product” testimonials.

Educate instead of pressuring – Create buyer guides, comparison charts, and educational content that helps people understand why your approach is different. When customers feel informed rather than sold to, they’re more comfortable investing in premium options. One of our clients does a great job with this – check out the Style Guide from He Spoke Style. It’s robust, it’s useful and it’s aspirational.

Strengthen your offer without discounting the price – Bundle complementary products, create exclusive access tiers, add valuable bonuses, or build in legitimate scarcity around timing or quantity. These strategies increase perceived value without training customers to expect price cuts. Limited-time offers around access or availability preserve the product’s value while creating urgency around the opportunity.

Make your brand experience consistent everywhere customers encounter you – Your website, social media, customer service, packaging, and follow-up communications should all reinforce the same level of quality and attention to detail. This includes your Google Business Profile, which functions as your second website in today’s search landscape. When the entire experience feels premium and thoughtful, customers are less likely to question whether your pricing is justified.

When Ecommerce Discount Strategy Makes Sense

This isn’t an anti-discount manifesto, I promise.. There are times when strategic price reductions can strengthen your brand and business, but they require clear rules and specific purposes.

Seasonal sales like Black Friday work because customers expect them, they’re time-bounded, and they can help clear inventory while introducing new customers to your brand at scale. The key is making sure these customers can see the value at full price during their first purchase experience, so they’re willing to buy again without waiting for the next sale.

Launching a new product line with introductory pricing can build momentum and gather reviews quickly. Customer acquisition campaigns using limited-time discounts for first-time buyers can work if you have strong retention systems.

The critical difference is having rules that protect your pricing power long-term. Limit how often you discount, set minimum margins you won’t go below, measure whether discounted customers buy again at full price, and make sure your sales have clear start and end dates. Most importantly, track whether your promotions are generating incremental revenue or just shifting purchases that would have happened anyway.

One of our clients used this approach during their first-ever Black Friday sale. Instead of endless promotions, they ran a single sitewide sale with clear rules: VIP early access for email subscribers, targeted messaging through Klaviyo, and a focus on converting dormant subscribers who had been on their list for months without purchasing. The result was 45% of their Black Friday revenue coming from new customers who finally converted, proving that strategic timing and clear value communication work better than constant discounting.

The goal is using discounts as a tool when they serve a specific business purpose, not defaulting to them whenever growth slows down.

Building a Premium Brand Strategy That Sells on Value

Pricing strategy comes down to a simple choice: you can build a business that attracts customers who value what you do, or you can build one that attracts customers who only care what you charge.

The e-commerce brands that thrive long-term are the ones where customers understand the value so clearly that price becomes a secondary conversation. They’ve invested in positioning that makes sense to customers, proof that builds confidence, and experiences that justify premium pricing without relying on artificial urgency or constant promotions.

This doesn’t mean being the most expensive option in your market. It means being the obvious choice for customers who care about solving their problem well rather than cheaply. When you get that brand positioning right, supported by consistent proof and education, customers stop comparing your prices to competitors and start comparing your solution to their problem.

The discount trap feels comfortable while you’re in it because the immediate feedback is positive. But the businesses that build real equity and sustainable growth are the ones willing to do the harder work of clarifying their value and proving it consistently, without training customers to expect financial incentives for every purchase.

Your pricing strategy is ultimately a reflection of how confident you are in your value proposition. When you know exactly who you serve, what problem you solve, and why you solve it better than anyone else, charging full price stops feeling like an ask and starts feeling like an obvious exchange.

Ready to Build Sustainable Pricing Power?

If you’re tired of feeling like you need to discount to drive sales, that’s usually a signal that your value isn’t coming through clearly enough in your marketing. At Plum Good Marketing, we help e-commerce businesses clarify their positioning, build proof that justifies premium pricing, and create marketing systems that attract customers who value quality over discounts. Whether that means optimizing every customer touchpoint or building strategic Black Friday campaigns that convert without training customers to expect constant discounts.

Want to explore what pricing power could look like for your business? Let’s talk.

Read the Comments +